Monday, 19 September 2016

Mberengwa: Parliamentary Public Hearings on the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill kick off


#MMAB Public Hearings Updates- Day 1


A community representative makes a point
Parliamentary public hearings on the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill kicked off today (19 September 2016) in the mining district of Mberengwa in the Midlands Province. The public hearing is part of a planned weeklong series which will be held across the country in the mining areas of Mberengwa, Bikita, Marange, Bindura and Penhalonga among others. The public hearings are legally conducted in terms of section 141 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe which provides for public participation in parliamentary processes.


In Mberengwa the hearing was convened at the Mberengwa Community Hall. Mberengwa is home to the once vibrant Sandawana Mine and small scale gold mining operations and thus the interest in the hearing was depicted by the high turnout.

Members of Parliament at the hearing
The Mines and Energy portfolio chairperson, Hon Daniel Shumba indicated that  the purpose of the Mines Bill public hearings is to address some of the challenges within the 1961 enacted Mines and Minerals Act. Various stakeholders attended the meeting ranging from local communities, small scale miners, local authorities, traditional leaders and government departments from the area and Zvishavane.

The hearing centred on 15 key issues within the Bill on which public opinion was being sought. The issues include: 

The identification of Strategic Minerals
Some of the participants
Composition of the Mining Affairs Board
The Cadaster of Mining Rights and Titles,
Exclusive Prospecting Licenses,
Farmer-Miner Relations,
Compulsory Acquisition of Land
Application of a Mining Licence/Lease 
Safety, Health and Rehabilitation Fund
Beneficiation of Minerals
Disputes in Mining
Prohibition of child labour.
Riverbed Mining by State Joint Ventures 
Utilisation of Financial Institutions
‘Use it or lose it’ Policy
Payments to Local Authorities

Some of the issues raised by the Mberengwa community relating to strategic minerals was on the need to include gold and diamonds by virtue of their strategic contribution the socio-economic development of the country.

Another matter of great concern was the proposed composition of the Mining Affairs Board. The Mberengwa and Zvishavane stakeholders stated that the board should include representatives of affected communities. Small scale miners felt , rightly, that due to their increasing role in the local economy, there ought to have more representation in the board as compared to large scale miners. A woman miner from Mberengwa with a heart problem was emotional about the unethical contestation of awarding of mining claims based on corruption and possibly an issue which the mining cadaster system can address.

The communal farmer-miner conflict that is apparent in the Zimbabwe mining sector was raised. The hearings in Mberengwa came up with demands for farmers to be entitled to agreed percentages on the mineral proceeds on their lands. Another interesting submission was that farmers should have land rights that include whatever is beneath the ground and above the ground.

The Mines Bill provides for a Safety, Health and Rehabilitation Fund relating to the maintenance of safety and environmental management in the mining sector. 
The reservation for riverbed mining for joint ventures by the States was strongly condemned. Major outcry was on the failure by government to undertake viable state-owned mining operations like Sabi and Jena Gold Mines. The participants proposed the government like all other actors not to be involved in river bed mining as this was deemed unsustainable.

In addition to these issues, there were legitimate concerns that the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill had not been given timeously and that too much powers have been given to the Minister and the Permanent Secretary in the ministry of mines. The people also indicated that there should be parliamentary oversight over the Ministry’s power over the cadasters system and the granting of licenses. If such views and concerns from the people are taken into consideration, Zimbabwe can have a more progressive mining legal framework that can better save the environmental, economic and social justice for the people.

[ZELA will be giving daily updates on the parliamentary public hearings on the Mines and Minerals Bill. On social media, please follow hashtag: #MMAB]
ZELA: Using the law to protect and preserve the environment.

Saturday, 17 September 2016

Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill: Another week of piecemeal parliamentary hearings?

The writer at a small scale gold mine in Mberengwa
The Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Mines and Energy will be going around the country conducting public hearings on the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill from 19 to 24 September 2016.
 The history of such hearings in Zimbabwe has been characterised by very minimal participation and attendance from members of the public. Where the few numbers had participated, at best the submissions have been mired in box-ticking and lack of basic understanding about the parliamentary processes and at worst by partisan violence as was witnessed during similar hearings on the Local Government Laws Amendment Bill in June 2016. Regrettably, the only meaningful submissions are usually from civil society, consultant companies and private business, whose voices are normally suppressed.
It would be sad if such a norm is repeated during the upcoming parliamentary public hearings for the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill. The bill covers a sector which is not only economically strategic, but which has also been mired by scandals such as environmental, labour and human rights violations.
Itinerary for team A during the public hearing
The extractive sector is potentially disastrous if it is not effectively regularised and managed. In Zimbabwe, the sector has made the gift of nature ugly, caused thousands of families to become paupers and created a few rich elites managing large mining companies which continue to play hide and seek games through tax avoidance, low wages, illicit financial flows and tampering with financial books. It is no wonder that one of the greatest books to come in recent times, dealing with the ill -governance in African natural resources, has a whole chapter dedicated to Zimbabwe. The book is “The Looting Machine:  Warlords, Tycoons, Smugglers and the Systematic Theft of Africa's Wealth” (2015, Willian Collins, London.) by Financial Times journalist Tom Burgis.
Discussions with miners and people who are settled in the mining districts of Gwanda, Zvishavane, Shurugwi, Hwange, Penhalonga, Mutoko, Bindura and Marange, among others, indicates that much work needs to be done for the planned parliamentary public hearings to be effective.
For starters, the people need to be educated more on the bills and parliamentary processes, e.g., how bills come into being. There is lack of information on parliamentary processes. Though the information is available in the Constitution, it is apparent that even during the 2013 Constitutional Referendum, a vast majority of the people who voted ‘Yes’ participated in a blindfold.
The strategic grouping of artisanal and small scale miners seems to have been let down by the draft Bill so far. This sector will continue to have a token single seat in the Mining Affairs Board regardless of the growing importance of artisanal and small scale mines to mineral output and employment creation. The small scale gold mining sector employs about 500 000 and in 2015 produced 7,4 tonnes out of the 18 tonnes produced countrywide, hence by calculation that was 40% of total gold production according to the Zimbabwe Miners Federation.
Other stakeholders in the mining industry such as labour, community members, civil society and environmental rights campaigners have also been largely ignored during the drafting processes. If there was consultation, it does not show in the Amendment Bill. To be fair, however, a handful of non-governmental organisations such as the Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association (ZELA), Southern African Parliamentary Support Trust (SAPST) and the Centre for Natural Resources’ Governance (CNRG) have done a sterling job of conducting research, pre-parliamentary hearing meetings, bill analyses and mobilisation.
It is, however, acknowledged that the Bill has some good provisions, mainly the proposed introduction of the Safety, Health and Rehabilitation Fund. The fund is aimed at rehabilitating environmental degradation caused by mining activities and, if managed effectively, will complement a similar fund that already exists. The latter is called the Environmental Fund and is provided for in the Environmental Management Act and managed by the Environmental Management Agency.
The Mines and Minerals Act should have been wholly overhauled after nationwide consultations, not piecemeal parliamentary public hearings. The Act should also have taken the progressive position of including mine labour since these are the direct creators of mineral wealth as well as the class which is exposed to the major dangers in the mining process. It is also the class which has been unjustly exploited both in Zimbabwe (evidenced by family strikes at Vubachikwe Gold Mine in 2015 and outside (South Africa’s Marikana Massacre in August 2012). In coming up with a piecemeal bill, Zimbabwe will only move a few steps beyond the colonial-capitalist 1961 Mines and Minerals Act. That will be potentially very unfortunate in terms of wasted time, financial and human resources.
[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist and lawyer based in Harare, Zimbabwe. He tweets at @LeninChisaira and is interested in Economic Justice, Human Rights, Leftist Politics and Environmental Justice. He blogs at cdetinashe.blogspot.com ]

Wednesday, 14 September 2016

Cde Thomas Deve: Remembering the life of an activist (Dec 1962-Sept. 2014)

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

Cde Thomas Deve(right) seated next to this writer
during the 2013 Zimbabwe Social Forum
This month, two years ago, journalist, civil society activist, leftist and Pan-Africanist Thomas Deve died at the age of 52. He suffered a cardiac arrest in the early hours of 7 September 2014, barely a month after attending the SADC People's in Bulawayo. Besides Justice Andrew Mutema, the High Court Judge and national hero who made a ruling that made the University of Zimbabwe reinstate me back to school after an unjust indefinite suspension for student activism, Cde Thomas Deve is the only other person whom I have decided to make time and write an obituary on, albeit after a two year delay.
I met Cde Thomas Deve soon after I finished law school and was working for a civil society that dealt with social and economic justice. Cde Deve’s workplace and mine were housed on the same premises in the Eastlea suburb of Harare. We got along very well and he quickly became an unofficial mentor, mainly due to our shared leftist world outlook. It was also rather ironic that the last activity he made a presentation at was a media sensitization workshop on the right to water that I had organised for journalists in central Harare.
Within a week of that workshop, I and the world heard of his passing in the early hours of that September weekend. Obviously he had spent the night at a show at the Book Café which featured Transit Crew, the reggae band that he loved, followed and reportedly mentored.
The ideals of Cde Deve were well-rooted in leftist politics and movement building. The discussions that we shared were almost always focused on the methods he and his comrades have tried to open up a leftist student organisation whilst at university. Later on, he had dedicated his life to research and campaigning against the harmful effects of globalization and capitalism in the Southern African region as well as the entire Third Word.
In following his ideals, he worked either directly or as a consultant for organisations such as the Deep Roots Foundation, Southern African Trade Information and Negotiation Institute (SEATINNI), Media Institute of Southern Africa-Zimbabwe chapter (MISA) and the Southern Africa Political Economy Series Trust (SAPES). He was also greatly active in forums such as the Zimbabwe Social Forum and the SADC People’s Summit.
With his passing, it was obvious that some civil society movements of which he had been a key advisor or anchor of, were going to go under mainly as a result of ideologically bankrupt programming. It is also disheartening to note that forums such as the Zimbabwe Social Forum of which he was a key participant and which we were both instrumental in organising in 2013, was last held in three years ago. Efforts to resuscitate such a critical platform any time soon appear very remote.
With a 2016 that has seen the rise of protests in the country, it is anyone’s guess that such activism in the absence of basic theoretical understanding of elementary political economy are bound to go round in circles.
In a year like this, Zimbabwe and the Third World must surely miss one of the most dedicated leftist activists and journalists of our time, in the name of Cde Thomas Deve. Adieu.
 [Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist and lawyer based in Harare, Zimbabwe. He tweets at @LeninChisaira and is interested in Economic Justice, Human Rights, Leftist Politics and Environmental Justice. He blogs at cdetinashe.blogspot.com ]


Monday, 22 August 2016

Prophet Magaya’s Rape Accusation: Exposing the arrogance of patriarchy and religion

By LeninTinashe Chisaira

“I’m not going to censor myself to comfort your ignorance”-Jon Stewart

Prophet Magaya (centre) at Court. [The Standard]
Prophet Walter Magaya of the Prophetic Healing and Deliverance (PHD) Ministries was arrested on Friday 19 August 2016 and charged with rape. He allegedly lured and raped a female university student-cum-congregant at a Mount Pleasant house in July 2015. What has followed the prophet’s arrest has been speculation from his die-hard fanatics that the arrest was politically motivated and was stage-managed with the complicit of the rape complainant.

The politics was alluded to with the consideration that various religious leaders have been speaking out against the worsening economic injustices and authoritarianism under the current Zimbabwe government.

However, some circles have been pointing out that the law must be allowed to take its course. I am in full agreement with the later. In as much as every person has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty, the rape complainant likewise has the right to speak out and seek justice without being labelled a “whore” , “prostitute” or “conspirator”.

Acceptable Rape

The problem with the Zimbabwean society is that it remains rooted in some of the worst forms of patriarchy. It is patriarchal practice that promotes the myths that when a woman accepts an invite to a man’s house, she must have herself to blame when she is raped. That mentality is animalistic. In fact, to say so is an insult to the animal kingdom. A woman has the right to say no, and that is a right that must be defended. Civilised society should never classify certain forms of rape and sexual assault to be permissible or acceptable. In this case, the question of whether the young women having conceded to be alone with the prophet at the house (as is alleged) should have foreseen that she would be sexually assaulted, is not relevant.

Complainants have rights

Rape victims and complainants, in the present incident and anywhere, deserve to be protected by society. This is especially the case when they are standing up to so-called powerful members of the society. People like the lady complainant have the potential to break the silence and build the confidence of other young women and men who occasionally find themselves in similar circumstances.

The young woman is no villain. Even if the accusation is later found to have been politically motivated, that still doesn’t make the rape complainant a villain. That can only strengthen the voice against making young women objects of either settling political scores or sexual pawns at the hands of patriarchal elements or religious rivals.

It is also highly undesirable for religious fanatics to continue exalting an accused person. The Saturday scenes at the Harare Magistrates (Rotten Row) Court with women kneeling and singing gospel songs in support of the accused Prophet Walter Magaya, was really unsettling. It is acts such as these that continue to fuel patriarchal crimes and to scare other young victims into submission. It doesn’t help that the Minister of Women Affairs herself reportedly gave the prophet a standing ovation in solidarity after the arrest.

On top of that, the prophet has paraded women congregants (including the complainant) to ‘confess’ during a church service that they were paid to nail him. That reminds one of the scene in George Orwell’s Animal Farm where animals ‘voluntarily’ confessed to anti-animalism behaviour. The animals in the story were sadly not saved by the confessions. Rather they were immediately carried to the slaughter by Napoléon’s dogs.

The law must take its course

Society and fellow congregants of both the complainant and the prophet ought to give the courts room to assess and evaluate evidence. Prophet Water Magaya and his followers are entitled to the presumption of innocence under our laws. Every accused person is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty.

Of equal importance is societal and congregants’ duty to respect the right of rape victims to seek justice without being roasted in the fires of the courts of public opinion. Religious fanatics and nightclub lawyers need to act and comment with caution and respect until the matter is resolved.

[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist and lawyer based in Harare. He writes on issues of economic justice, politics, human rights and the environment at www.cdetinashe.blogspot.com and tweets at @LeninChisaira]


Friday, 12 August 2016

Responsible Investment in the Natural Resources Sector: An analytical profile of the mining sector in Zimbabwe


Download from Academia
The call for responsible investments has been rising slowly in the past four years in Zimbabwe. A number of initiatives have been placed and more need to be placed in order to respond to rising corporate failures and poor corporate governance practices by shareholders and investors especially those in the natural resources sector. Some mining companies in Zimbabwe have been accused of unsustainable business practices that ignore community rights and environmental impacts. Above all, the investment environment in Zimbabwe has largely characterised by lack of shareholder activism, unsustainable business values, poor corporate governance and corruption. In an ideal setting, investors must use their collective position to drive sustainable business values in the companies they invest in. 

This paper explores the fundamental concept of responsible investments, gives a contextual analysis of investment practices in the natural resources sector while exploring opportunities for driving sustainable and responsible investing in Zimbabwe. 

The natural resources and extractive sector remains one of the major fiscal contributors, although it is associated with high social, economic, political and environmental impacts. In early 2016, the President of Zimbabwe, Robert Mugabe exposed that amounts going up to US$15 billion have been externalized by diamond mining companies operating in the Marange area. This is highly significant in a country whose annual budget is a mere US$4 billion.

A nation that places people's needs as a priority above private profits should particularly ensure that investments and business decisions are done after thorough assessments of human rights and environmental justice.

However, political inconsistences and doubtful capacities on the part of the Zimbabwean government agencies and authorities have characterised the response to investment in the country. Zimbabwe's legal, policy and political environment has been characterised by glaring inconsistences and political whims. Much study is needed to constantly re-look at the impacts of the legal, policy and political environment on investments in the country.
The existing laws contain some important provisions that should guide responsible investments, however lack of capacity and sometimes lack of political will has hindered progress towards responsible investment. To determine whether responsible investment is effectively catered for and enforced, the existing legal and policy framework on investment needs to be reviewed. The review will further be aimed at ensuring that future investment initiatives result in considerable gains and benefits for the majority of the people surviving in the current set-up of an economy that has been branded as an enclave economy.


PLEASE NOTE: This is the introduction to the research paper. Download the fulldocument free of charge here. You can also get hard copies from the Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association (ZELA). Email: tinashe@zela.org Website: www.zela.org . Call/Whatsapp: +263 775678928 

Download from Academia
[Rodney Ndamba is the Executive Director of the Institute for Sustainability Africa. Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an environmental lawyer and researcher and tweets at @LeninChisaira]







Monday, 8 August 2016

A Heroes’ Day review of Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter.

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

Zimbabwe commemorates its Heroes Day in August each year. The 2016 commemoration comes at a time when the political relations between the state, citizens and most interestingly the war veterans  are not cordial. In that regard, a review of one of the latest and most informative memoirs about the liberation struggle, Wilfred Mhanda’s Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter[1] seems in order. The author, Wilfred Mhanda’s[2] nom de guerre was Dzinashe Machingura hence the nickname Dzino in the title of the memoirs. Dzino was one of the fiercest critics of the post-war Zimbabwean state for which he spent his youthful days fighting for.

Dzinashe Machingura is undoubtedly one of the most distinguished yet disinherited freedom fighters to come out of Zimbabwe. He contributed to the success of Zimbabwe’s liberation war at a time when allies of the Zimbabwean struggle such as  “(President Samora) Machel …lamented the Zimbabwean nationalist leadership, which he did not consider equally committed to a long and difficult fight to liberate the country.”(p. 94).

It was also a time when military commanders in the Zimbabwe National Liberation Army (ZANLA) like General Josiah Magama Tongogara were in incarceration in Zambia following President Kenneth Kaunda's clampdown on the ZANLA High Command in the aftermath of the assassination of Herbert Chitepo, Zimbabwe’s first lawyer and then chairperson of the revolutionary Dare reChimurenga (p62-66).

In those troubled times, Dzinashe Machingura reveals how he and other commanders on the ground formed the ZIPA on 25 November 1975 to carry on the armed struggle .The army was a merger between ZANLA and the Zimbabwe People’s revolutionary Army (ZIPRA). The Military Committee of ZIPA included Solomon “Rex Nhongo” Mujuru , Dzinashe Machingura, Elias Hondo, James Nyikadzinashe, Saul Sadza, Parker Chipoera, Webster Gwauya and Tendai Pfepferere from the ZANLA side. The ZIPRA contribution consisted of Nikita Mangena, John Dube, Enoch Tschangane, current Vice President  Phelekezela “Report” Mphoko, Ambrose Mutinhiri, David Moyana and Dr Augustus Mudzingwa (p. 96-97). ZIPA was the entity that was to open military fronts and to resuscitate the liberation war in earnest (p. 100-107). However its role in history seems to have been officially blacklisted.

 Dzino’ memoirs honestly admit the crucial role of the  Marxist/socialist ideology in being  the lifeblood of the Zimbabwean liberation  struggle. This ideology was sin instilled in the freedom fighter from the training stage. Dzino indicates that “At the end of the formal training programme, before proceeding to the transit camp in Kongwa in the Dodoma region, most of our time was spent on productive activity and on extra political lessons. A voluntary group of about eight, headed by Dick Moyo, was formed to study the basic tenets of Marxism-Leninism. I was part of that study group.”(p. 24). In that regard, the current neo-liberal cum nationalist capitalism models the nation finds itself in is the mere result of a struggle betrayed and a very Zimbabwean model of state capture.

The revolution devours its children


French royalist journalist Jacques Mallet du Pan’s[3] adage that “the revolution devours its children” is well known and well documented and has already been proved to be true in most revolutions that have occurred around the world through the history of humanity. Of particular interest are the French Revolution with its Reign of Terror[4] and the Russian Revolution with the Stalinist Purges[5]. For Africa, Chinua Achebe[6] creatively narrates about that kind of dog eat dog politics in post-revolutionary Africa in his novel, Anthills of the Savannah[7].

The book under review , Dzino, exposes the origins of persecution that took place in the liberation struggle. These were the  roots to most of the problems that face Zimbabwean politics in the present times. These political problems include the politics of using disciplinary hearings to settle political/personal scores  as well as to boot out dissent even from former comrades in arms.

Wilfred "Dzinashe Machingura" Mhanda aka Dzino
With independence getting nearer again,  Dzino and other were suspected of harbouring political ambitions using ZIPA and they were lured into an underground prison in Maputo (p. 186-193). President Robert Mugabe , in July 2016 confirmed the incident whilst issuing warning against the dissenting leadership of the Zimbabwe National Liberation War Veterans Association (ZNLWVA). He warned that  “During the war, we would punish defectors severely . . . we kept them underground like rats, in bunkers”[8], highlighting the truth in Dzino’s memoirs.

A history distorted


The book, most importantly, serves to provide an additional picture to those that have been presented  by the other few Second Chimurenga historians like David Martin and Phyllis Johnson, whom Dzino himself accuses of being biased towards President Mugabe in their book, The Struggle for Zimbabwe[9].

 Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter also exposes the often told lie that freedom fighters fought for the struggle selflessly and without payment. The selflessness has already been  demystified by war vets’ self-centred demands of the late 1990s and at the 2016 War Vets Meet Patron indaba. In the book, Dzino writes of freedom fighters receiving a weekly stipend, in  addition to cigarettes  (p. 28)

The only blight in Dzino’s book is the last third of the book, written as “Reflections on Post-Independence Zimbabwe” and the conclusion. This section is so different from the tone of the early ideologically coherent parts that is appears as if it was inserted by someone else. The section goes into overdrive to reflect ordinary Zimbabwean civil society’s neo-liberalism. These include attacks on the Fast Track Land Reform Programme (p. 228). However it is up to each reader’s perspective to interpret the book.

Every person must read Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter


In conclusion, every person interested in Zimbabwean politics and liberation must read Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter. It has been said that socialists are the memory bank of the revolution, because they read and know how to pursue revolutionary actions backed by revolutionary theory and vice versa. In the same vein, activists  and politicians on Zimbabwe should , as the nation makes reflections on its  Heroes’ Day, make a habit of learning from the works that touch on Zimbabwe’s past as this  possibly shapes the future political and economic structure of the country. In addition to books like Martin and Johnson’s The Struggle in Zimbabwe, Maurice Nyagumbo’s With the People, Didymus Mutasa’s Black Rhodesian Behind Bars, Ian Smith’s The Great Betrayal, Munyaradzi Gwisai’s Revolutionaries , Resistance and Crisis in Zimbabwe, Joshua Nkomo’s The Story of My Life and Edgar Tekere’s A Lifetime of Struggle, people must definitely read Dzino: Memories of a Freedom Fighter.

Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist, socialist, lawyer and writer based in Harare, Zimbabwe. He tweets at @LeninChisairaand blogs at www.cdetinashe.blogspot.com




[1] Published by Weaver Press, Harare, 2011
[2] (b. 1950 - d. 2014)
[3] (b. 1749 – d. 1800)
[4] (6 September 1793 – 28 July 1794
[5] (1936 to 1938)
[6] (b. 1930 - d. 2013)
[7] Published by Heinemann, 1987.
[8] Newsday, “Mugabe in brutal crackdown threat”, 28 July 2016, accessed 8 August 2016 at https://www.newsday.co.zw/2016/07/28/mugabe-brutal-crackdown-threat/
[9] Published by Faber and Faber, London, 1981

Friday, 5 August 2016

The scary politics of fighting against someone instead of fighting for an alternative

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

Wednesday anti-bond notes and anti-unemployment march (263chat)
Zimbabwe still continues to be every activist’s dreamland by each passing week. People are courageously taking to the streets and they know what they are fighting against: rampant unemployment, some undemocratic leaders and some corrupt politicians.

Sadly, when trying to fix the economy and the politics, it is not enough to say the struggle being waged is a mere fight against one or two corrupt leaders or the rampant unemployment of university graduates. What is wholesome is to state the clear nature of the economic and political alternatives being fought for.

In economics, there is growing danger that people will easily fight on behalf of foreign capital for the latter to come and invest. But the same people run the risk of being blind to the ordinary worldwide investor tradition. That is a tradition of wage slavery, exploitation of labour and abuse of environmental rights. No group has come out fighting for an alternative employment culture that will be buttressed by workers’ empowerment, just labour practices and full workers’ democracy in the workplace.

Likewise, the struggle against authoritarian rule and human rights violations must be complemented by the fight for a clear political alternative. The struggle must clarify what kind of democracy is being fought for. Is it the same old bourgeoisie democracy or its social democracy or its wholesome socialist democracy? Ignoring these terms as academic or abstract norms can be another recipe for confusion.

Most messaging in opposition politics and protest groups in Zimbabwe and indeed most countries, is heavily obsessed with the “Down with X” and ‘President X Must Go” mantra. Rarely do you find groups knowing exactly what they are fighting for as much as they know who or what they are fighting against.

Protesters and opposition should be about alternatives, mostly ideological to the ruling system. They should be frameworks on economic and political structures to be utilised after victory. Otherwise the struggle will be futile.

In the #FeesMustFall days, South African students did not just fight against fee increase, they fought for Free Education. In Zimbabwe everyone knows ‘who must go’, but sadly the opposition and protest narrative lacks a viable alternative. There is lack of impetus or support for alternative economics. Politics don’t just start and end at institutions of government, but also on the economic drawing table.

Worthwhile struggles and allies


The only worthwhile struggle in the political environment is one where people are conscious of the way the economic, political and social structure will be organised after the so called ‘revolution ‘or revolt. Otherwise there is grave danger that such struggle effort will either wane with time, lead to disastrous consequences or be hijacked by opportunist elements.

In the same vain, it is futile to build alliances for the sake of building them. United fronts should be built on shared visions for the future. Building alliances with anyone and everyone, and yet lacking any tangible shared goal is unfortunately to be expected whenever people are just angry at the visible target but do not know what the struggle seeks to build as an alternative. Will some of these allies be strategic in the building of an alternative economic and political system in the country?

In conclusion, during the early days of independence in the African colonies, there rose a system known as neo-colonialism where the people got voting right and black leaders but the economic superstructure and exploitation remained the same or even got worse. People must be wary of that.

 One can only salute the fearless people who are exercising their democratic rights to protest and to communicate their messages to the government of the day in various creative ways. What is unsettling is the realisation that such efforts can easily be in vain if people don’t shift from merely fighting against someone and become consciousness of the alternative Zimbabwe they are fighting for. Aluta.

[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is a lawyer, activist and former student leader based in Harare. He tweets at @LeninChisaira and blogs at www.cdetinashe.blogspot.com ]