Monday, 1 August 2016

On Relations between Mines and Mining Communities in Zimbabwe (My Radio VOP interview transcript)

Lenin Tinashe Chisaira in the Radio VOP studio
The transcript is from a Radio dialogue focusing on “Relations between Mines and mining communities in Zimbabwe’ broadcast on 19 July 2016. The show features Lenin Tinashe Chisaira, an environmental lawyer and researcher representing the Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association[1]. The interviewer’s name is Tafadzwa Muranganwa from Radio Voice of the People (VOP)[2], an independent radio station. Radio VOP broadcasts via satellite on the channel called ChannelZim.  The radio broadcasts on the internet as well, on www.channelzim.net. The audio of this interview recording can be accessed on these YouTube links [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzTGWG0V1-k  and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JogBxIPyryM ]

Tafadzwa (Radio VOP):       Welcome to the programme, Mr Chisaira. Sorry we delayed a little bit. We were failing to get connected, but now we are on. Thanks you, Mr Tendai [sic] Chisaira for gracing Radio VOP...Radio Voice of the People and we want to discuss the relations between mines and the mining communities. Of late we have had reports...I was reading The Manica Post[3] where there was suspected diamond miners who were nabbed. But we have seen over the years the mining communities who were around Chiadzwa[4] were crying foul that the government gave them a raw deal with the Community Ownership Trust that was launched, it never came to fruition…a whole array of problems they were saying they were facing even when we know that the diamond fields in Marange were so much richer and we suspect this US$15 billion which went missing was from Marange. Welcome to the program, Mr Chisaira.

L. T. Chisaira:     Thanks a lot, Tafadzwa. Well, this is a very interesting discussion especially if we look at our economic status as Zimbabweans. You know it's barely a month since the President of the nation himself faced the nation and informed them that up to $15 billion have been lost[5]. Most of it obviously was a result of illicit financial flows whereby money just leaves the country on channels that are not even known to the people who are responsible for the national budget, the national fiscus, and revenue collection. Some of the money gets lost through what are called transfer mispricing and trade mis-invoicing where they fake these amounts of prices that they would have sold their minerals to their fellow subsidies of the various multinational companies.
So it is a very interesting discussion, the issue of mines and mining communities because if we look at the issue in a very frank manner, basically our economic status, the mining economic environment in Zimbabwe is not divorced from the entire economic strata, from the entire economic system in our society whereby we have big business, we have multinational companies, we have big mining companies that are mostly focused on profit-making at the expense of people and environmental rights. So it is a very really... i don’t think I should say interesting, but it’s a very scary discussion to conduct in that whilst we are conducting this discussion, people are really suffering from environmental injustice, from economic injustice as a result of the faults of these mining companies.
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP):   But Mr Chisaira, there are some allegations from the mining companies' management where they are saying that some of the demands by these mining communities are not justified...where they want their own folk in the mining areas to be employed. And some of them would be saying the people do not have requisite skills so that they can be employed. If you heard from those clips from Marange, some were saying there are not giving them even those jobs that are for the less skilled. What’s your take regarding the management of some of these mining companies who are saying some of the demands are not justified?
L. T. Chisaira: I think that really is a very dishonest accusation coming from mining companies. Because when you see...most of the demands that come from mining communities may be classified mainly under three main demands. One, because we have this issues that we call Local content whereby as civil society, for example my own organisation, the Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association, we really fight, we really campaign for these organisations to respect issues of local content development and this has three main components.

One is that mining companies should have... should adopt a policy of employing locals, which is local employment.
They should also develop a policy of procuring some basic items, you know a mining company has many workers but they can even go as far as buying their basic vegetables from far-away communities instead of the people who are in the immediate locality.
Then there is also the issue of infrastructure development , for example if you are a mining company in rural setting, you also needs to use roads which you use to transport your  minerals, your raw materials , your people etc. etc. So it’s just a matter of saying, if we have Murowa Diamonds in rural Zvishavane which uses a dust road to transport its minerals up to now, I think that’s really unfair. So by developing their own roads, it will also benefit the communities, so I don’t think these are not justifiable demands. Because when a company builds a road, it benefits the company itself as well as the community.
When a company employs locals, it also benefits in terms of maintaining good relations between the company itself and the people whom they would be neighbouring with. And most of these jobs that they demand or ask for from the mining communities. They are really maybe unskilled jobs or those that require very low levels of skills. Indeed when it comes to skilled labour or those that really need very much technical people or highly qualified or highly educated people...yeah the companies there have the liberty to, and I think the right to employ people who are from outside the communities. But for basic jobs, so the most important thing is that these companies should be able to provide records and justifications that shows that for these menial labourers we have taken people from the communities, but for those that require much technical or require much expertise, we have outsourced labour .So I don’t think the demands by mining communities are unreasonable.
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP): I don’t know from our listeners, what you think. You can do so by writing to us on our number 0774 214 539 or you can phone us via our landline number. If you are outside of Harare prefix that number with 04 748 766. If you are in Harare dial the number directly ...748766. But coming to you, Mr Chisaira, that impasse between the mines and the mining communities, I think the policy...the decision makers you know could be a factor in trying to bring that impasse. But what are your observations regarding the policy makers in making sure that there is a cordial relationship between the mines and the mining communities. So far as an organisation what do you make of policy makers in regards to this issue?
L. T. Chisaira: I think that's also in three phases because, first, I think...just in brief, there are some very painful personal stories especially from the communities we work with around Chiadzwa. There is this one lady who lost up to fifty head of cattle after they drank polluted water that had been polluted by these diamond mining companies. On top of that, you see that i itself is an example of an impasse between mines and mining companies.
                      Then when it comes to policy makers, recently[6] we were talking of the Mines and Minerals Amendment Bill which is before parliament. One of the most unfortunate things about that bill, though it has some progressive provisions, the most unfortunate thing is that it doesn’t provide for adequate Free, Prior and Informed Consent whereby a mining company, when they intent to embark on a major project, the community members around that area are supposed to be informed freely, thy should be informed prior to the project takes place and they should be informed so that they don’t just go to meetings and be spoken down to but they also attend those meetings with some basic knowledge about what impacts the mining project will have on their environment, will have on their livelihoods, will have on their families. But that is not being done and the policy makers have not really done a good job with the Mines and Minerals Amendment Act.
Then on the other hand, we also have some policy makers who seem to know that they are doing, who seem to know their jobs very well. For example, recently we had the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee (on Mines and Energy)taking the Permanent Secretary , Prof Gudyanga over the way he was handling the Zimbabwe Consolidated Diamond Mining Company issues[7] which is one of the most touchy issues for people in the diamond mining areas. They seem to be doing their jobs very well. Then also as the Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association as an organisation we provide a platform each year, what we call the Zimbabwe  Alternative Mining Indaba , first we conduct them at provincial stage then at the national stage. The 2016 one will be held in Bulawayo. I’m sure you will be there.
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP): You are inviting me?
L. T. Chisaira: Yeah, we really partner with various radio stations. We have partnered with Ya FM[8], then with Diamond FM[9], when we conducted our provincial ones. But so, that’s another platform where we try to resolve that impasse, where we bring together community members, we bring together legislators, even up to cabinet members, Minsters and the mining companies themselves. We try to provide those platforms so that they engage. But you know very well that Mining companies are not really honest on their engagements with community members. They seem to look down upon them.
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP):     We have one comment from one of our listeners and she says, “Mining companies are unfair to community members.” I don’t think there is anyone…Most people are pointing accusations to the mining companies. But they are some communities where other people there are onto artisanal mining. Some are saying they are not willing to regulate their operations. What do you think about these?
L. T. Chisaira: About artisanal mining?
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP): Artisanal mining.
L. T. Chisaira: Well, artisanal and small scale mining in itself...it’s also a very strategic sector for the Zimbabwean economy. Because as you know, well, due to our economic situation...unemployment, drought, etc. The mining sector, especially artisanal and small scale mining can provide some adequate livelihoods for most of our people especially in the rural areas. But then the problem, like you have rightfully pointed out, the problem is lack of formalisation. It is a sector that has not been adequately formalised, though obviously this Mines and Minerals Act, for the first time provides some very little benefits for artisanal, sorry, for small scale miners but we still have problems with artisanal miners. Because at one time the government , the RBZ[10], they came up and said “We have a No Questions Asked Policy”[11] whereby if someone is an artisanal gold miner , he can approach gold buying centres and sell his gold without questions being asked about the legality of his operations, but still it’s not a clear field. As an organisation and as people we really need to urge the policy makers, the government, etc., to really look into the issue of artisanal miners with the seriousness it deserves.
Tafadzwa (Radio VOP):     The listener went on to say “You will be shocked to know someone from Victoria Falls getting a sweeping job in a mine in Mutare, but the locals can’t”. Listeners if you want to input into this program you can do so by texting us or Whatsapping. Our number is 0774 214 539. 0774 214 539. You can also place a call on our number 748 766. 748 766. If you are outside Harare, you can prefix that number with 04.
                        Thank you, Mr Lenin Tinashe Chisaira for gracing our radio. Time is not on our side. I think you did a wonderful job in trying to make sure some of our listeners get a picture of what’s really happening between mines and mining companies and we have seen that the picture is not looking good. Mines are being accused of failing to develop the mining communities. Thanks you, Mr Chisaira.
L. T. Chisaira:           You are welcome, Tafadzwa. Thanks you for inviting me to Radio VOP.



[3] State-owned newspaper from Manicaland Province
[4] Diamond mining area
[5]The Herald, “Miners robbed us, says President” , accessed at  http://www.herald.co.zw/miners-robbed-us-says-president/
[6] Newsday, “Bill should plug leakages in mining sector: Zela”, accessed at https://www.newsday.co.zw/2016/05/21/bill-plug-leakages-mining-sector-zela/
[7] The Herald, “Parly Grills Gudyanga” , accessed at http://www.herald.co.zw/parly-grills-gudyanga/
[8] Radio station based in Zvishavane, Midlands Province
[9] Radio station based in Mutare, Manicaland Province
[10] Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
[11]The Herald , “Artisanal miners embrace new RBZ policy” , accessed at http://www.herald.co.zw/artisanal-miners-embrace-new-rbz-policy/

Saturday, 23 July 2016

Zimbabwe's interesting new role as a melting pot for political ideas

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

If one is asked about the best thing coming out of the current Zimbabwean question, one can confidently say it is the growing space for contestation of political ideas. Barely a day passes without one coming across a pointed comment on Facebook or Twitter alluding support for one of the various economic, political and social ideas being forwarded by certain individuals, institutions, social movement organisations like #Tajamuka, #ThisFlag, civil society, politicians, economists, activists and even by the public and ruling party characters.

Lenin Tinashe Chisaira
Some progressive commentators in Zimbabwe are taking debates beyond social media and embarking on the further energetic step of penning opinion pieces and articles in support of their ideas. Contestation of ideas is dominant in alternative media platforms such as blogs and diaspora media websites. In just this past week, one encountered thought-provoking writings from people like Takura Zhangazha, Miles Tendi, Munyaradzi Gwisai, Tamuka Chirimambowa and others.

 The exchange of radical and reactionary ideas is almost a reminder of the stories and pictures we have seen in history books about the political cafes that dominated revolutionary France in the 18th and 19th century.

The place for theory

Any serious movement for economic, social and/or political reforms should be backed by progressive ideas/theories otherwise the result would be senseless anarchy or fatal defeat. The Arab Spring remains a living reminder of the futility of movements that lacked clear ideological foundations.

 In the words of Vladimir Lenin, the Russian revolutionary leader, theorist and historical figure in his 1902 political pamphlet entitled What is To Be Done? Burning Questions of our Movement:

“Without revolutionary theory there can be no revolutionary movement. This idea cannot be insisted upon too strongly at a time when the fashionable preaching of opportunism goes hand in hand with an infatuation for the narrowest forms of practical activity… the role of vanguard fighter can be fulfilled only by a party that is guided by the most advanced theory”.

Lenin is a man whose books, theories and tactics delivered the great October socialist revolution where for the first time the working class overthrew a tsar and took over the running of a society. It is such ideas that should be revisited in the Zimbabwean context where all leading formations are trying hard to capture the eternally relevant and potentially revolutionary urban and rural working class.

When people are focused on political debates, a small segment even argue for otherwise hidden ideas such as Marxist theories. Hence is encouraging for people like this writer who in other times barely comes across encouraging progressive content in the media. So it was highly interesting to read about classes once again in a recent article by Takura Zhangazha. it is a pity though that he identifies himself as a social democrat. He would make a good communist.

The good and the bad of political debate

The contestation of ideas is both healthy and bad. The good thing is that the environment opens up for debate and progressive ideas and even gives voice to some people who under ordinary circumstances prefer to be silent. The focus on ideas eventually leads people to seek opinions and writings in non-traditional mediums and this is a worthwhile pursuit.

The bad thing with political debates is when some cadres take things personal. For instance, there is a rising culture among some activists that says certain characters should not be criticised. These say we have reached a stage where some people should be regarded as sacrosanct in order to avoid the struggle being compromised. To them, criticism is unwelcome. Unfortunately, such sentiments are the bedrocks of a totalitarian society.  One of the features of a totalitarian society has been defined as “centralisation of power and values in the hands of the leader. This centralisation of power allows the decisions of the leader to reach and influence the people without checks or mediation from other institutions with their own political agenda or values.” These sentiments should not be a feature of the current wave of pro-democracy movement-building in Zimbabwe. Every idea and every person should stand the test of criticism and democratic debate.

The future

In a nutshell, the future of viable political ideas contestation in Zimbabwe should involve unfettered debate, even when such involves the criticism of some people’s heroes. There must be debate on social media and on the ground. Discussion forums initiated by residents’ movements, students’ unions, civil society and other groups have never been more necessary. There is need for this society to allow free debate and the testing of alternative theories, political ideas and ideological questions. Such debate and robust contestation of ideas can never be adequately exhausted on social media, moreover on Twitter with its 140-characters-per-tweet limitations.

Everyone, led by the intelligentsia, needs to effectively strengthen, initiate and participate in the current discourse on Zimbabwe’s economic, political and social future. That is genuine freedom of expression.


[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist, lawyer and researcher based in Harare, Zimbabwe. He tweets at @LeninChisaira and blogs at www.cdetinashe.blogspot.com]

Thursday, 7 July 2016

The rise of organic protest, opportunism and the private press- #ShutDownZim



Riot police beat up an ordinary protester in Mufakose during the 06 July protests (Source: Newsday)
The first week of July 2016 has started on a fiery note. Harare, Beitbridge and Bulawayo have been burning.  Questions have been asked about the faces of the people or individuals behind the general July people’s protests and the 6 July stay away. Some sectors of the society, for their own interests have begun to dishonestly ascribe to some social media characters these obvious results of general resentment against the bad governance in Zimbabwe. They have chosen to ignore that touts can organise themselves, and likewise cross-border trades do not need social media prodding to agitate their grievances. The same with civil servants who had virtually had a months’ salary taken away from them by the Ministry of Finance.

Organic Protests

The July protests by Zimbabweans were organic. That is the answer. At Beitbridge, informal traders were incensed after the Ministry of Industry and Commerce issued SI 64/2016, also cited as the Control of Goods (Open General Import Licence) (No.2) (Amendment) Notice, 2016 (No.8) on 17 June 2016. The statutory instrument (SI 64/2016) is a law which seeks to control the import of basic goods and foodstuffs into the country. The merits or demerits of the SI are not the subject of this opinion. However, it cannot be doubted that people were not consulted. Hence the major grievance seemed to have been on lack of consultation and adequate notice from the government. Due to its usual disregard of the people’s views, the government got its just deserts when the border town of Beitbridge burned.

With the heat from Beitbridge still on, touts and public transport operators staged some powerful protests in Harare and Bulawayo, notably in the poor, working class suburb of Epworth, just outside eastern Harare. Epworth is a community which lies in the forgotten periphery of the capital city, and is usually associated with prostitution, school dropouts and crime. This is also a community which is not really the territory for social media activisms and where there is virtually little to no Wi-Fi availability. But where people suffer the worst of economic crisis. It is a community where the majority of unemployed youths, decided to say enough s enough and to face down the ever-worsening harassment by traffic police on combis, which was their main source of livelihood.

Whilst these protests were ranging, civil servants were mobilising for strike against lack of payment of June wages by the government. Organisations such as the Rural Teachers Union of Zimbabwe (RTUZ) had been calling for action since the day the salary postponement was announced (which incredibly was the same day SI 64/2016 was gazetted). Likewise, the youth coalition/movement known as #Tajamuka had been fearlessly leading protest-actions from the front, at bank queues and at courts.

Media bosses and fear for radical actions

Now despite the actions by these various organics groups and movements, it shocking when on the day after the stayaway, the private press have decided to ascribe the people’s efforts to have been caused by a mere call from a certain social media character. The intention behind that is obvious and shall be analysed here.

Lenin Tinashe Chisaira
Most of the private press in zimbabwe is owned by business interests. These interests, no matter how they may try to support pro-democracy activism, themselves fear the rise of anti-capitalist sentiments. They feel threatened themselves when they witness organic movements calling for the burning of business and private property. This is because media bosses also attend meetings and play gold with fellow business executives from targeted sectors. In addition, media bosses also invest in various businesses such as in the transport and supermarket sectors.

They try to water down radical protest and place moderate characters as front men, denying credit to the grassroots. The Daily News and Newsday editions of 07 July 2016, have gone at length to claim that the recent 06 July #ZimShutDown2016 / #ZimbabweShutDown / #ShutDownZim action was called by people whose recent disregard for vibrant protest and whose efforts at demobilising and dismissing visible ground protests by groups like #Tajamuka, opposition parties and the general populace have been well known and well documented. Genuine people and their grievances as well as the frontline actions of organic movements like #Tajamuka are deliberately and shockingly being side-lined.

In a nutshell, through it is good to acknowledge the power of social media, it is also pertinent that we do not forget the most factual conclusion that can be carried away from the events of these weeks. The fact is that it is the people’s actions on the ground that can shake a system, i.e., the vibrant actions of ordinary people who rise up and express genuine grievances against, among other things, police harassment, corruption and the exploitative taste for lavish living by government elites. It can never be sole twitter and social media activisms that can uproot a system. Social media activism is good, but only when it supplements vibrant action on the ground.

At the other end, throughout history, the private press and the state media have almost always tried to hijack or distort people’s efforts. This is due to considerations for profit-making, politics as well as  the protection of private business interests and property. However, history will be the judge. Bravo, the ordinary people of Zimbabwe and those in foreign lands who are in solidarity.



[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is an activist and lawyer by profession. Twitter: @LeninChisaira ; Website: www.africafightnow.org ; Blog: www.cdetinashe.blogspot.com ]

Friday, 1 July 2016

Bond Notes: Are the fears genuine? - Part 2

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

Gov. John Mangudya of the RBZ at the launch of bond coins in 2014
In this part 2 of this writer’s bond notes opinion, there is need to look at how the law should be used to protect the aspirations and needs of the ordinary person and not just those of the elites. The law must be flexible. Hence this part will invoke some basic legal arguments for the practical need for bond notes by the bank-queuing public. One must hasten to remind the reader that the writer is openly supportive of radial economics and anti-neo-liberalism.

The law must serve the ordinary people.

Zimbabwe is founded on respect for certain values and principles (section 3 of the Constitution of Zimbabwe) which values include recognition of the worthy and inherent dignity of each human being and respect for the country’s diverse cultural and traditional values. The state must ensure that its people, especially pensioners who selflessly built the nation in their younger years, must be able to enjoy comfortable lives devoid of indecent queues and the indignity of cash shortages. Section 68 of the Constitution provides for the right to administrative justice. The elderly, and the workers and peasants are equally entitled to administrative conduct that lessens burdens on their lives and that is prompt in addition to being impartial, proportionate to the extent of the economic problems and reasonable in a real economic crisis.
The Law must be progressive and responsive to the aspirations of the people, including economic aspirations. Therefore, the government of the day, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ), big business, professionals, elites, etc. must be pro-people and organic in their conduct. The law should never have a narrow and inflexible interpretation.

It is within the rights of the central bank to safeguard hard currency since it is prone to abuse by business and the elites. Section 49 (1) (b) of the RBZ Act gives the RBZ the power to maintain international reserves which can be in the form of foreign exchange in the form of notes or coins or account balances held by the bank in foreign currencies. It suffices that the Constitution already gives the central bank the powers to regulate the monetary system, to protect currencies in the interests of balanced and sustainable economic growth and to formulate and implement monetary policy. (Section 317(1) of the Constitution.) The RBZ, as the institution empowered by the Constitution and by Section 47 of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe Act [Chapter 22:15] to deal with exchange rates and monetary policies in Zimbabwe must indeed be a bank of the ordinary people. The RBZ must act to ease the suffering of the people in a cash shortage environment. It must come up with measures that address bank queues; that alleviate the plight of people who are travelling long distances to banks and who will be awaited by hungry families and dependents.

Flexible solutions

Rather than mere fault-finding, there is need for the Zimbabwean society to understand that the Zimbabwean crisis needs wholesale reforms in the long run. But in the short run there is also need to strategically built our economy through flexible and creative solutions that alleviate the plight of our people.

Lenin Tinashe Chisaira
Big business needs to incentivise or re-initiate the use of currencies such as the South African rand. Businesses that import goods from South Africa, should likewise mostly sell their goods locally in SA Rand, rather than in US dollars. Instead of mere denigration of the use of bond coins and notes and amplifying their disadvantages in the import sector, business should rather encourage the wider usage of alternative currencies such as the Rand. The rand fell into general disuse some time ago yet Zimbabwe gets a whopping 60% of its import from South Africa. For the sake of economics not politics, big business need to explains how currencies which were both at 49% usage at the start of the official multi-currency era in 2009, later transformed into a 95% usage for the US dollar versus 5% usage for the Rand in 2016.

The banking and financial service sectors need to encourage people to adopt the use of plastic money. Ecocash and Steward bank are commendable in this respect. These sectors should also encourage the use of real time gross settlement (RTGS) services. In that regard it is critical that points of sale machines be available in almost all places where cash transaction ordinarily, including rural areas, farms, mines, shops, service stations, vegetable markets, council offices and growth points.
All this is not hidden or bookish information. The problems is when vocal people overlook economic and legal information that is available in the public domain. The capitalist system is one that requires research and reluctantly, some caution, before we unwittingly make life difficult for the ordinary bank-queuing person through narrow elitists legal interpretations, ignorant alarming and massaging the ego of big business and the elites.

Last but not least- Arrest the Corrupt.

On another note, and beyond economics, it is worthwhile for the government and the central bank of Zimbabwe to note that public confidence in them has been eroded. Everyday news features scandals of massive abuse of public resources. The culprits always seem untouchable. Without doubt, if government changes course and starts fighting corruption through imprisonment of perpetrators and recovery of stolen assets, the trust may come back. Economics is about people and the solutions should mainly centre on the ordinary, working people.


[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is a lawyer and former student leader at UZ. He is a student of Economic Regulation and writes here and at www.africafightnow.org  in his personal capacity. Twitter: @LeninChisaira]

Wednesday, 29 June 2016

Bond Notes : Are the fears genuine? - Part 1

By Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

Many voices and temperatures, have arisen over the proposed introduction of bond notes by the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ). In a statement issued on 4 May 2016, RBZ Governor, John P. Mangudya, announced the forthcoming issue of $2, $5, $10 and $20 bond note denominations. Bond currency is not a novel idea, considering that Zimbabwe has been using bond coins since 2014. However, the notes have become the most prominent of a raft of measures proposed to deal with cash shortages. These shortages had metastasised societal   inequality. Disproportionately, the burden of cash shortages almost always falls on ordinary people, vendors, workers, civil servants, soldiers, policemen, small scale farmers, small scale miners and pensioners. These people brave the winter in bank queues awaiting uncertain cash withdrawals.

A bank queue in Harare: A result of cash shortages
Yet it seems that the few corrupt, politically connected individuals and corporates who have contributed to this severe cash shortage through externalisation are being shielded from responsibility for this mess. They seem to be shielded behind monetary policies that are camouflaged to appear as if there are pro-poor. Focus seem to have been shifted from bringing culprits to book as part of immediate diagnostic measures. Without justice, a situation where the poor will continue to be discriminated against in terms of access to the dollar and will be left to largely transact in much maligned bond notes which are at risk of transactional loss of value against multi-currencies, seems imminent.

A matter of basic economics

It is Government credibility however, not economics, that is at stake. The fear and mistrust run deep.
When economic rationale is used, bond notes appear to be a sanitiser in the current Zimbabwean economic situation.

As a background, the current debate on bond notes sprang up after the country secured a US$200 million loan facility from a development bank known as the African Export-Import Bank (Afreximbank). The facility was meant to stabilise foreign currency exchange and to incentivise foreign exchange earnings. This money is not immune from externalisation.

Externalisation and a skewed balance of payments, or simply the unsustainable model of importing more that the country exports, are among the main reasons why Zimbabwe went into a punishing hard currency shortage. On imports, the country has already gone deep into the mode of importing basic goods that should ordinarily be produced locally such as maheu, bottled water, milk, potato crisps, cereals, fruit juice and even camphor creams and petroleum jellies.

It is interesting to note that resistance against the bond notes has been mainly instigated and initiated by elites in society, made up of supermarket owners, big business, professionals and churchmen people. These and other well-to-do sections of the society have hyped up the resistance against bond notes to an extent where the so-called ordinary person on the street has become bewildered, alarmed and more confused. This is despite the fact that the same ordinary person has been enduring winter nights in bank queues with fellow ordinary people.

 To the ordinary person in the bank queues, bond notes can be a life saver. On the other hand, to big business, professionals or rich clergyman intending to externalise hard currency, it is a raw deal.

Bond notes and resuscitating local industry

It is apparent to anyone with a knowledge of basic economics that as long as the country imports more than it exports, there is trade deficit. The country experiences a skewed balance of payments. In such a situation, there is great need to work towards the resuscitation of local industry rather than importing more. An exclusively Zimbabwean medium of exchange, is an incentive towards such resuscitation and uplifts the livelihoods of vendors and small scale producers in mining, farming and industry.

The bulk of our sources of hard currency (which I won’t refer to as liquidity) is derived from exports and for this to occur, we need to incentivise the main producing areas, and these are not banks or supermarkets or churches, but small scale farmers, tobacco farmers and small scale miners and their support service providers in the form of vendors and siyasos in addition to large scale miners of gold, diamond and ferrochrome. Therefore, the bond notes are going to be welcome development to vendors, tobacco farmers as well as small scale gold miners, who desire immediate cash after selling their product, which produce in the long run can enable Zimbabwe to get back into meeting its balance of payments.

Admittedly, to get hard currency we also need foreign direct investment just as we need money from our people in the diaspora as well as lines of credit. But these two areas contribute just a mere 20% to our sources of hard currency.

It is apparent that the economic case for bond notes should be balanced against the re-assurances of trust in the government. For the confidence to be achieved, the government must exit its willingness to sanction the externalisation of currency and to bar corruption. These ills have an adverse effect on the resuscitation of local production.

-To be continued


 [Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is a lawyer and former student leader at UZ. He is a student of Economic Regulation and writes here and at www.africafightnow.org  in his personal capacity. Twitter: @LeninChisaira]

Tuesday, 28 June 2016

A year of Lumumba's sex-tape, UZ HIV students and state-led objectification of young women



By Daphne Jena and Lenin Tinashe Chisaira

The Day of the African Child is commemorated each year on 16 June. The day is held to remember schoolchildren who were massacred whilst protesting apartheid-education policies in the Soweto township of apartheid South Africa in 1976, exactly forty year ago.
Co-author Daphne Jena (right) speaking at an AfricaFightNow.org event

And exactly 40 years later, the year 2016 has been an eventful year in the victimisation of the young in neighbouring Zimbabwe, especially young women.
In May 2016, state papers in Zimbabwe screamed headlines claiming that almost half of the University of Zimbabwe (UZ) students were HIV positive. Within a month the same state media was to expose former Zanu-Pf activist and parliamentary candidate Acie Lumumba’s sex tape featuring an unidentified young woman.
The two incidences are dangerously linked. For starters, both were exposed by the state media. Secondly there were openly aimed at victimising vocal sections of the Zimbabwean society. The report stating that “almost half of students who underwent HIV testing at the University of Zimbabwe were positive” was immediately buttressed by calls for the limitation of free association in campus’ halls of residences.
The second incident, which was poorly disguised as a scoop, was aimed at punishing former Zanu Pf Harare Provincial Executive member and shadow MP for Hatfield constituency, Acie Lumumba who had just resigned from the ruling party citing rampant corruption and lack of good governance in party and government. He claimed his sex tapes got into state hands after police searched his house in June 2016. The sex tape immediately came to a government-owned tabloid, H-Metro and the same day, the video began to circulate on the internet. So much for state spying on people’s bedrooms.
In as much as the 47% HIV article article published by Herald and the Chronicle on a research purported to have been done by the National Aids Council seems to tarnish the image of the institution, it also compromises the reputation of the students especially female students. The Lumumba sex-tape on the other hand, highlights the patriarchal notions of treating young women as objects that can be used to settle political scores without even the courtesy of consent or offering dignity to young women.
The state paper could have done by covering the face of the young woman rather than splashing her image and body on the public eye. Basic human dignity and respect for citizen privacy should have entered the conscience of the alleged police searchers, political bullies as well as editors of the tabloid.
Blaming female students and young women
Each time there is a discussion on the sexual behaviour of people, be it in society as whole or about students in tertiary institutions, most of the blame seems to fall on female students and young women. Female students and young women are often judged based on the rumours on their morality and sexual behaviour in institutions and in general society.

This is mainly perpetuated by the assumption that most female students and young women engage in sex work with rich married men in exchange for money and other material favours. Such rumours have been with us for so long such that, they have been slowly accepted as truth for almost every female student and young woman in the country. This excuses men in general and male students in particular from playing a part in any of the sexual activities in society and in tertiary institutions.
The article which stated that 47% of students at UZ who underwent testing are believed to have been positive, is likely to have a negative impact on the female than male students. When the UZ Vice Chancellor Levy Nyagura gave a comment, he pointed to the fact that an increase in the number of pregnant students was a cause for concern as if that is a direct relation between being pregnant and being HIV positive. Furthermore, his comments make falling in pregnancy as a crime. Already in his comment, Professor Nyagura ignores the fact that for a woman to conceive, there is a man involved.
Such statements perpetuate the attitude which is already deep rooted in our society that a woman is to blame for every relationship between two people. It is rare for men an d male students to be judged based on where they learn or what they do, it is always the women and female students who are at fault. Unfortunately, this does not end with street talk but it even translates to the abuse that female students, young women or employees experience in workplaces.
We have heard of cases of female students and young women who are sexually harassed when they go for work related learning, and some even fail to secure places as a result. The assumption among some men that female students and young are easy or are of loose morals are based on the rumours and beliefs that always implicate female students.
If someone has heard that students from a certain institution are ‘easy’, that person may decide to try their luck on any student from that institution expecting to get a positive response. A negative one, will lead to disappointment and hence opens way to for abuse. To compensate for the rejection, one may then decide to offer the opportunity that the student is seeking in exchange for sexual favours, worst cases end up in sexual harassment or rape.
No more patriarchy
To sum it all, it has become a sad development that state organs themselves are taking centre stage in the perpetuation of such stigmatisation. The UZ reports and the Lumumba sex tape expose state-sanctioned patriarchy at its worst. It is the duty of ever responsible citizen to defend violations of individual liberty and to protect victims of a bulling patriarchal society.
To that end, though the UZ retracted its statements as a face saving measure and a young women exonerated herself from the sex tape, the media and law-enforcement organs in Zimbabwe must look at their consciences and ensure that they do not become such sadistic pawns and perverts in the broader political game.
A continuation of such victimisation and patriarchal bigotry against female students and young women will only serve to destroy the hopes, healthy sexualities and freedoms of an already-suffering demographic, populace and nation.
[Daphne Jena is a women’s rights activist. Lenin Tinashe Chisaira is a former SRC Vice-President at the University of Zimbabwe. They write in their activist capacities. Twitter: @DaphneJENA and @LeninChisaira .First published on 17 June 2016 on NehandaRadio]

#ThisFlag: A good idea, but the Zimbabwean struggle will not be tweeted.



The social media craze in Zimbabwe going under the hashtag #ThisFlag has been around for a little over a month now. The campaign is also heavily subscribed by Zimbabweans in the diaspora and by other sympathisers beyond borders. As of the third week of May 2016, newspaper editorials and opinions have begun to be written about the social media campaign. Indeed, critical questions around the issues of corruption, abuse of power, economic mismanagement and general lack of good governance are being raised under the #ThisFlag campaign by Zimbabweans and other netizens. 

Ambassadors and government officials are also part of the showcase. What is missing and scary about it, is that it has shifted struggles from the streets to the internet. Many brave people whose track record in fighting democratic struggles in Zimbabwe is undoubted, have also regrettably fallen for the exclusive social media campaign and hashtagging.

The campaign, sadly remains an exclusively social media one, without any meaningful offline presence. This raises questions about its real objectives, ideology and program of action.
Respectfully it is a good idea, and an attractive one for social media, photo galleries and for those wishing to exhibit Photoshop expertise. But for any meaningful struggle against the Zanu-Pf government or any government or oppressive system in the world, the social media only works whilst mobilising for real-life protest, campaigns and mobilisation efforts. This is what the Zimbabweans rallying behind the campaign have failed to grasp. Characteristically, social media without offline presence is a demobilising factor.

2016 is a year of resistance dumped on the internet

The Zimbabwean flag


Any person who follows protests and believes in them, would have regained hope in 2016  being a  year of resistance. There were powerful occupations and strikes at two giant parastatals by disgruntled workers just a few months back. In…. workers stuck camp and occupied the Grain Marketing Board’s (GMB) head-offices in Eastlea. Within a few months, rail workers and their families embarked on another powerful industrial action and occupation of the National Railways of Zimbabwe’s (NRZ) Rugare marshalling yard. The country’s biggest opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC-T), after a long period of sleeping on duty, eventually managed to mobilise and carry out a powerful and massive demonstration in the streets of Harare. The latter action prompted the ruling party’s youth league to organise its own ‘One Million Man March’ in support of the 92-year old president of the Republic, Robert Mugabe.

Hence 2016 was promising to be a year of the streets. Painfully, within a few weeks, all the anger that should have been poured on the streets was relegated to social media. People began to find comfort in tweeting the #ThisFlag hashtag with whatever issues they have and ending at that. Even the so-called leaders of the #ThisFlag campaign, whom this writer, shares certain WhatsApp groups with, openly declared that the movement was not going to pour into the streets .In other words, #ThisFlag was going to continue raising issues and expressing grievances with the way government was running the country, but only by (ab)using individualistic methods of posing for photos with wrapped flags, and posting the photos on social media. In a few weeks’ time, street activists and faceless social media accounts began a backward trend of clicktivism over activism.

Social media should supplement, not substitute direct action

Social media had been utilised and achieved great results for physically protesting people (emphasis on ‘physically protesting’) during  the Arab Spring  uprising in Egypt and Tunisia, the Occupy movements in the United States, the #FeesMustFall campaign in South Africa (which this writer was physically part of and of which he wrote an article on Nehanda Radio ), and recently during the campaign of a socialist candidate Bernie Sanders in the United States. In all these occasions, social media was used to supplement direct action and to mobilise for living campaigns. Never was a government or system removed by clicktivists using the social media aloneas their sole arena for resistance as is the case with Zimbabwe’s #ThisFlag social media campaign.

Similar Flag but we are different Zimbabweans

Whilst the intentions of the organisers of #ThisFlag may indeed be noble and innocent, real politics and ideological understanding would show that trying to bunch together fellow Zimbabweans for just being under the same flag, without regard to social classes, is a gross and dangerous misrepresentation of patriotism. As a poor African, I have more in common with a poor African in another country than I can ever have with a ‘fellow’ Zimbabwean  government minister , capitalist or rich pastor or preacher. Hence to bundle all and sundry on the grounds that we accidentally share the same nationalist flag takes us nowhere. A genuine movement can only be class-based and even transcend borders and not be brought together by a nationalist flag. The world is now a global village and many of our citizens are more concerned with people to people solidarity across borders and not fake comradeship under a flag. A company director, rich church pastor or a cabinet minister may share the same nationalist, albert same flag with a vendor, a sex worker or a street lawyer like myself, but we can never share the same interests. That is a great error on the part of activists rallying under the #ThisFlag campaign. What we want in life and in politics are different. Just last year, most of us wept when the Supreme Court delivered an anti-labour judgement, yet other Zimbabwean businesspeople ululated. It is inconceivable that today we can stand side by side with such ‘fellow’ Zimbabweans, our interests can never be the same just because we share the same flag. As the working class, the poor and radical intellectuals, we will be our own liberators and we will liberate ourselves on the streets not via Wi-Fi.

The Way Forward includes Offline Activism

As a way forward, activists should either get off their backs and smartphones, scrutinise their allies, craft a programme of action backed by progressive ideologies and solidarity with genuine movements within and beyond nationalistic borders, mobilise and get into the streets and face down police baton sticks, teargas and beatings if they want governments to notice. Otherwise  this elitist social media noise only serves to entrenchexploitation, alienate activists from the mass of society and demobilise and undermine people who believe in genuine direct action such as NRZ, GMB and opposition grassroots activists. Unfortunately, Zanu-Pf has already seen the power of offline presence over social media with the adoption of the counter #OurFlag hashtag by the party’s One Million Man March organisers. Photoshop, modelling for the camera with brand-new flags and tweeting in the comfort of private bedrooms and offices is a dangerous illusion that must be broken as soon as yesterday.


Having said that, it is indeed naïve to dismiss the strategic role of social media, but it is only strategic as long as it is used to mobilise and publicise real life actions. I am an avid user of social media myself and an advocate for the use of alternative media as opposed to mainstream media, which is usually controlled by financial or political interests, but never once do I fool myself that when I am on social media alone I am fighting a struggle. Social media is important and democratic, but only when it is used as a support strategy by an action-oriented people. 

In that regard, I sign off with a quote from UK socialist Chris Bruno. He wrote in a 2012 issue of the Socialist Worker newsletter: ‘As a supplement to, not a substitute for, old tactics, social media plays an important role. It has the ability to reach those who have neither the time nor desire to participate in the existing political infrastructure thus far. It provides another effective way to organize and mobilize for our actions, and it provides a truly alternative media — one that is organically created by the masses and gives us a more complete picture of what’s going on beyond our doorsteps.’ (emphasis mine). It is important that we acknowledge social media for what it is - a mobilising tool for real life action - and utilise it as such, but to substitute street action as is the current case, is a historical disaster.

[Lenin Tinashe Chisaira coordinates AfricaFightNow.org! and tweets at @LeninChisaira. This article first published 3 June 2016 on AfricafightNow,org!]